| Year | Horse | Owner | Breeder | Sire x Dam, Broodmare Sire |
| 2010 | Leap Frog | Becky Henson | Montara Farm | Great Lengths x Mineva, DEPUTED TESTAMONY |
| 2009 | not awarded | |||
| 2008 | Alabama Girl GB | Amanda Geci | FLORIDA SON (GB) x Affair With Black (USA), FARMA WAY | |
| 2007 | Nearly Doubled | Becky Henson | Caroline Spracklin | Near Dawn x Doubly Delighted, DOUBLE ZEUS |
| 2006 | Triple Six | Jeannine Bergeron | Jeannine Bergeron | Night Relic x Virtuous Native, HALO |
| 2005 | Triple Six | Jeannine Bergeron | Jeannine Bergeron | Night Relic x Virtuous Native, HALO |
| 2004 | Golden Baby | Amanda Geci | NORTHERN BABY x Fool For Gold, TOM FOOL | |
| 2003 | Glorified | Caroline Spracklin | TRANSWORLD x STRONGHOLD, GREEN DANCER | |
| 2002 | Glorified | Caroline Spracklin | TRANSWORLD x STRONGHOLD, GREEN DANCER | |
| 2001 | Native Sky | Jeannine Bergeron | Jeannine Bergeron | Sky Pilot x Virtuous Native, HALO |
| 2000 | Native Sky | Jeannine Bergeron | Jeannine Bergeron | Sky Pilot x Virtuous Native, HALO |
| 1999 | Native Sky | Jeannine Bergeron | Jeannine Bergeron | Sky Pilot x Virtuous Native, HALO |
| 1998 | Native Sky | Jeannine Bergeron | Jeannine Bergeron | Sky Pilot x Virtuous Native, HALO |
| 1997-1995 | Not Awarded | |||
| 1994 | Last Hurrah | Caroline Waid | Master of the Hunt x PRARIE GRASS, RED RYDER | |
| Year | Horse | Owner | Breeder | Sire x Dam, Broodmare Sire |
| 2010 | Aurora Borealis | Alia Whipple | Clear Light Farm | NORTHERN BABY x Dark Skies, SKYWALKER |
| 2009 | Aurora Borealis | Alia Whipple | Clear Light Farm | NORTHERN BABY x Dark Skies, SKYWALKER |
| Year | Horse | Owner | Breeder | Sire x Dam, Broodmare Sire |
| 2010 | Anne With An E | Becky Henson | Tanya Rawson | Buckthorn x Julie Ann (GB), Your Edict King |
| 2010 | Anne With An E | Becky Henson | Tanya Rawson | Buckthorn x Julie Ann (GB), Your Edict King |
| Year | Horse | Owner | Breeder | Sire x Dam, Broodmare Sire |
| 2010 | Aurora Borealis | Alia Whipple | Clear Light Farm | NORTHERN BABY x Dark Skies, SKYWALKER |
| 2000 | Aurora Borealis | Alia Whipple | Clear Light Farm | NORTHERN BABY x Dark Skies, SKYWALKER |
| Year | Horse | Owner | Breeder | Sire x Dam, Broodmare Sire |
| 2010 | Black Stark (USA) | Stephanie Cepeda | Foxfire Stables | Black Hammer x A STARK IS BORN, GRAUSTARK |
| 2009 | Gallant Knight (USA) | Stephanie Cepeda | Cadence Farm | Gallant Sky x Alandria Princess, ROCKY |
| 2008 | Gale (GB) | Amanda Geci | Amanda Geci | GLACIAL STORM x Affair with Black, FARMA WAY |
| 2007 | Grand Bay | Stephanie Cepeda | Tanya Rawson | Black Hammer x A STARK IS BORN, GRAUSTARK |
| 2006 | Star-Crossed Realm | Ashley Getsay | TRANSWORLD x Wrecked (GB), BUSTED | |
| 2005 | Moonlight Princess | Amanda Geci | Amanda Geci | ALLEGED x Moonlit Dance, CARO |
| Year | Horse | Owner | Breeder | Sire x Dam, Broodmare Sire |
| 2010 | Genuine Dynamo | Beth Elliot | Cadence Farms | DYNAFORMER x Genuine Pride, Storm Dancer |
| 2009 | Alandria Pilot | Stephanie Cepeda | Foxfire Stables | Sky Pilot x Alandria Wave, Gallant Sky |
| Year | Horse | Owner | Breeder | Sire x Dam, Broodmare Sire |
| 2010 | Slew City Fever (USA) | Coraline Girard | Cadence Farms | DYNAFORMER x Genuine Pride, Storm Dancer |
| 2009 | Ball Fever (AUS) | Tanya Rawson | Foxfire Farms | BLACK MINNALOUSHE (USA) x Ball Away, BALMERNIRO NZ |
| Year | Horse | Owner | Breeder | Sire x Dam, Broodmare Sire |
| 2010 | Holy Quest (NZ) | Coraline Girard | Coraline Girard | Kessem Crusader (Aus) x Mother Eve (Aus), Tristan |
| 2009 | Ten Point Buck (USA) | Becky Henson | Montara Farms | Buckthorn x Lady Alandria, Richochet Step |
| Year | Horse | Owner | Breeder | Sire x Dam, Broodmare Sire |
| 2010 | Pen Name (USA) | Jeannine Bergeron | Nighthenge Farm | Bally Mist x Mighty Pen, MOKHIEBA |
| 2009 | Pizzicato (USA) | Stephanie Cepeda | Clear Light Farm | COZZENE x Didn't Mean It, DYNAFORMER |